|
| |
The nuclear reactor number 4 at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant in Ukraine,
exploded on 26 April 1986 releasing 2.6x1011 MBq of radioiodine. The most
heavily contaminated areas were southern Belarus, northern Ukraine and
the Bryansk and Kaluga regions of Russia. Immediate protective actions
were not taken and thyroid doses of 2-5 Gy in the most heavily contaminated
areas were found. Since the estimates were made in May-June 1986, radiation
from short- lived isotopes, mostly 132I and 133I,
could not be taken into account. A few years after the accident increased
risks of thyroid cancer among children were reported and the increase has
continued (33,34).
In Belarus, 390 thyroid cancers among children have been diagnosed between
1986 and mid 1995, compared to 7 thyroid cancers in the 9 years preceding
the accident giving a nearly 56-fold increase in incidence (35). The cancers
were considered highly aggressive, infiltrating surrounding tissue and
showing a high rate of lymph node metastases. Similar findings were reported
from Ukraine, 211 juvenile thyroid cancers were diagnosed 1986-1994 compared
to 25 for the period 1981-1985(36). The increase started in 1990 and was
calculated to be 7-10 times that of the period preceding the accident.
For a long period of time no increased risk of childhood thyroid cancer
was found in Russia, not even in the regions closest to Belarus and Ukraine.
In 1991 a "prophylactic systematic medical examination" of populations
living in the south west district of the Bryansk region, closest to the
Gomel area, was started. A total of 62 thyroid cancers among children and
adolescents at time of accident has been found, 19 of these being exposed
in utero. A case- control study is under way.
Conflicting results have been reported for the so-called clean-up workers.
Thyroid examinations, including ultrasound and selectively fine needle
biopsies, were carried out in 1,984 Estonian clean-up workers (38). A total
of 201 workers (10.2%) revealed thyroid nodules at ultrasound and 2 papillary
thyroid cancers was found. It was concluded that no apparent effect related
to the accident was found. In a recent study of thyroid cancer risk in
119,000 Russian clean-up workers, 47 thyroid cancers were found giving
an ERR per GY close to what has been seen in children after external exposure,
5.31 (95% CI 0.04-10.58)(39). A peculiar finding was that the highest risk
was not noted for those working in April-May 1986 but in June the same
year. This might indicate that other factors, such as external exposure,
may play a role in the increased thyroid cancer incidence.
Today very few question the etiology of the thyroid tumors found among
the children in the Chernobyl area even though the contribution of other
risk factors than ionizing radiation is not clear. However, even though
the Chernobyl accident will give the scientific community the opportunity
to study the carcinogenic effect of radioiodines there is still a lot to
be done. So far most of the studies have been aggregate or ecological studies,
where thyroid cancer incidence was related to time periods or geographical
areas without individual doses or even residency taken into consideration.
In order to address influencing factors cohort or case-control studies
have to be undertaken. The number of individuals and the dose range must
be sufficient since these are the factors influencing the statistical power.
|
|