An approach to the patient with a low serum TSH
  A careful physical exam, especially the thyroid, should always be carried out, since the presence of a goiter would make the diagnosis of thyroid dysfunction more likely. Since the serum TSH is now the first thyroid function test obtained in patients suspected of thyroid dysfunction or in the screening of older patients, or those at risk for thyroid disease, an abnormally low value should be pursued. In this regard, a level below the lower limits of detectability in any given assay raises the suspicion of thyrotoxicosis. A patient with a TSH value below the normal range but still detectable is probably not thyrotoxic and the test should be repeated in a few months. Further studies are warranted in patients whose serum TSH is undetectable and who are not receiving thyroid hormone therapy. We usually obtain some measure of thyroid hormone levels, primarily a serum T 4 , free T 4 (or index), and total T 3 (or free T 3 ), and thyroid TPO and Tg antibodies. If either of the circulating free thyroid hormones is elevated then the patient almost certainly has some form of overt thyrotoxicosis. If circulating thyroid hormone levels are normal, suggesting subclinical hyperthyroidism, a serum TSH should be repeated in a few months, since the suppressed TSH may be a transient finding. If either or both of the thyroid antibodies are positive, autoimmune thyroid disease is present and would warrant more careful follow-up, since the first and only abnormality in early Graves’ disease may be a suppressed serum TSH. Whether a serum thyroid stimulating immunoglobulin (TSI) should be obtained in such a patient is debatable, but we usually do not in this situation.

Other tests that can help to clarify the presence and etiology of subclinical hyperthyroidism in patients whose serum TSH remains suppressed with normal circulating thyroid hormones are as follows, and not in any specific order. First, a blunted or absent serum TSH response to TSH-releasing hormone (TRH) would suggest a diagnosis of subclinical hyperthyroidism 15 . Second, a thyroid 123 I uptake and scan revealing areas of hyperfunction raises the possibility of autonomous nodule(s). Finally, a serum thyroglobulin (Tg) might prove to be of interest. If the serum Tg is in the upper normal range or elevated, this would suggest that the thyroid may indeed be hyperfunctioning and secreting excess Tg. On the other hand, if the serum Tg is in the low-normal range, endogenous thyroid hyperfunction is less likely and if the serum Tg is suppressed, then thyrotoxicosis factitia should be ruled out.